This post is essentially a copy of a letter I just sent to a formerly close Christian “brother” and pastor at a mega church who seems to have thoroughly lost his bearings and begun feeding at the Trump trough of hate and corruption. Instead of championing the cause of the immigrant, the orphan, the sick, the elderly, the poor, and the abused, my associate supports Trump, the most xenophobic, self-centered, short-sighted, hateful and categorically unChristian candidate for president that our country has ever known. There is literally nothing about Donald Trump, neither in his personal life nor recommended public “policies,” that has anything to do with Jesus, his teachings, and his exemplary life. Of all people who should know better, of all those Christians who are aware of biblical teachings and the anti-christ character “who will lead many astray,” I cannot fully express how utterly baffling and disappointing this is to me.
Sadly, my former “Christian” friend and his casting aside Christ for Trump is not unique among the many otherwise intelligent and good Christians I grew up with and/or came to know as an early adult. I will never understand how so many have so thoroughly neglected the core teachings of their alleged “most cherished beliefs” as found in the biblical text and personified by their so-called LORD and savior, Jesus Christ. Their supplication, adulation and general sycophancy and excuse-making to dizzy up themselves into whole heartedly voting for Trump and his politics of hate and patently unChristian policies, attitude and life in general tells us everything we need to know about who their true master is: it ain’t Jesus. Shame on them. They are an embarrassment.
Of particular emphasis below are my friend’s two-tier attack on the transgender community and recipients of welfare, with particular emphasis on welfare recipients who are people of color. My oh-so “Christian” friend cites Republicans’ and Trumps’ position on each of these as evidence for why he will vote for Trump, believing the lie that subjugating transgender people to his particular religious beliefs and taking away already-meager government assistance programs from those in poverty really are “the most loving and most Christian” things he could advocate. No really, it IS that bad. It’s insane.
Here is my letter. He has yet to reply.
-Corbin
Dear (Mr. X)
I sent this to your work because I couldn’t find your new home address. Maybe the upside to receiving my letter at church is that you can read it at church and not burn home-time on it. Either way, this is very much about your religion and personal beliefs, so maybe it’s appropriate to receive as part of your official duties. 🙂
I have been thinking a lot about the political aspects of our recent conversation. I understand the peril of ignoring the inner voice that tells me “Do not engage!” But here’s the thing: I have been unable to determine if the most loving thing I could do would simply be to remain quiet and let you go your own way, or if the loving thing would be to point out the hypocrisy I see and how it may be leading you astray (at worst) or undermining your Christian credibility (at best). For my part, if I was being a hypocrite with my stated “most cherished” beliefs and it was undermining my credibility, I would absolutely expect a good friend to tell me. Otherwise I’d just be pissing into the wind thinking it was rain. Ick. So that’s the question I have for you: “If you were making a huge mistake, would you want to know?” Because I think you are making a huge mistake. There are massive inconsistencies between your stated religious beliefs and your continued support of Donald Trump politics. I know you don’t value my friendship as you once did, and that’s okay. Even as the somewhat distant friend that I’ve become, I think you deserve to be told rather than my taking what is surely an easier and passive route by not caring enough to engage. That ain’t me.
I acknowledge your expressed sentiment that one can be a Republican or Democrat and still legitimately be a Christian. I agree. I understand that people can have legitimate differences regarding which political machinations and general political parties are best suited to advance their most cherished values. Prima facie, there is nothing untoward about wanting one’s government to reflect their values. But it gets tricky with secular governance of a diverse set of individuals and groups whose values are drastically different. We do not live in a theocratic society, and it is not beholden (or at least should not be beholden) to any specific religion nor its related doctrines. If you doubt this, I’d ask you to consider how you would feel if the religion adopted by our government was something akin to Islam or really anything besides your preferred version of Christianity. Would you smile at the notion of being saddled with Sharia Law? I am going to venture a guess: No. As much as a Muslim wants his government to reflect his Islamic values, imposing Sharia Law is simply inappropriate for our government. This is the tension that we must both acknowledge and accept as Americans, as citizens in a secular democracy full of people whose values are different and even irreconcilable at times. As such, we must also reject the rise of Christian Nationalism, which seeks to impose Christian values and hierarchies on people who otherwise have no interest in them. And our refusal to impose nominally “Christian” values on non-Christians is not because we value principles of secular human governance above the teachings of Jesus, but rather because we value the teachings of Jesus, particularly his instructions on how believers are to treat others, namely, that we are to treat them as we would have others treat us.
At this point it becomes important to distinguish between nominally “Christian” values that we have convinced ourselves of, such as your personal feelings about transgender issues, and compare those with the direct, unequivocal instructions straight from Jesus’s mouth. Is it a Christian value to impose your beliefs on others, or is it merely prioritizing your feelings over the clear instructions of Christ? The answer is pretty obvious to me.
If you wouldn’t want Muslims, Mormons, or Moonies dictating how you are able to live your life, then Jesus commands that you not do the same to them. The same would go for some hypothetical transgender high priestess from the Church of Gender Nonconformity: Regardless of their sincerely held spiritual beliefs, they shouldn’t get to dictate how you chose to identify, what bathroom you use, or who you marry. In that sense, wanting your government to reflect your most cherished values entails you allowing others to live lives free from your particular religious convictions. If you take Jesus seriously, you need to re-align your advocacy here. And that’s not just so you can do better at following Jesus. It’s also so you won’t let your feelings get in the way of helping introduce others to Jesus. Other people’s sexuality, identity, and conformity to certain cultural gender expressions are simply none of your business. It is not an issue between you, and a transgender individual and God; it is between them and God. And what if your feelings on the issue are totally wrong anyway? What if a transgender individual IS becoming exactly who God created them to be by transitioning? Who are you to say? It seems that you are to willing to put God in a box and dictate who and what he can or cannot create. Is it possible that he doesn’t value the same rigid and narrow binaries that you do? Are you really so arrogant to believe you know the mind of God and what he cannot do? Either way, I am convinced that Christians can never go wrong by simply introducing people to Jesus. But Christians go catastrophically wrong when they try to force other people to do (or be) such and such rather than letting Christ do any work if it needs to be done. My point is this: when you want to require others to conform to your religiously held notions, you are not following Jesus. He did not and would not do that. Why do you?
Jesus’s take on the golden rule is also reinforced in his so-called second greatest command,”love your neighbor as yourself.” The point is the same; irrespective of another person’s theological commitments (or lack thereof), if we wouldn’t want them imposing their religious beliefs on us, we must not engage in the same sort of moves against them. Jesus didn’t offer any exceptions. He did not say, “Treat others as you want to be treated as long as they think, identify, (or vote) just like you do.” Neither did he say, “Treat others the way you want to be treated unless you think you know what’s best for them.” No caveats. No exceptions.
After all, Jesus never forced others to live as he lived or to live according to his teachings. He never instructed his followers to take their beliefs to Caesar so that he might impose them on others through Roman governance. You know as well as I do that Jesus refused to be a political leader. His approach was that his followers lead others by example, by their testimony, and by their refusal to get mired in the same sort of power plays and bids for wealth and clout that the “gentiles” were so taken with. Jesus called his people to be radically different from the “world” and how it managed its affairs. “Loving” one’s enemies? Going the extra mile if your enemy forces you to go one? Being poor in spirit? Wut? This was as much nonsense to the world in the 1st century as it is today. But Jesus was a radical. He trounced the conventional wisdom because it had nothing to do with the Kingdom he envisioned. I don’t think you’d disagree with that assessment, at least I hope you won’t, but I also hope my previous questions about your politics have given away where I am going next: How does your support of Donald Trump fit into the radical example and teachings of Jesus?
I asked you in (state) the same question I always ask people who claim to follow Jesus but vote Trump: “If Jesus’s values and teachings are your most cherished ones, which of these are found in the person or policies of Trump?” Like everyone else I’ve posed that question to, you didn’t like it and immediately shifted away from Trump and towards what has become the new Republican platform. I understand why. There simply are no relevant examples of Trump reflecting Jesus’s values or teachings either as an individual or a politician. Substituting in the Republican Party is really the only move to make there. Even so, I think you should be aware of how you dodged the question. It can tell you something if you let it.
When it comes to Trump, as I learned in the tactic you yourself have leaned on many times in our conversation: “You know I’m right.” He’s a conman who does the opposite of Jesus’ teachings. Sermon on the Mount? Nope. The Beatitudes? Not even close. Fruits of the Spirit? Don’t make me laugh. By it’s fruit, you will know the tree? Yeah. Ok, let’s go with that one. What fruits do we see in Trump’s life? How many divorces? How many rape and sexual harassment charges? How many civil and criminal convictions (so far)? How many failed businesses? How many pornstars? How many bankruptcies? How many lies? Is he a loyal friend and husband? Is he kind? Is he patient? Slow to anger or speak? Does he ever consider others better than himself? Or is he the exact opposite of all these, 24-7-365? Does he treat others the way he wants to be treated? We both know the answer. So you shouldn’t be surprised when I call your support of the man hypocritical. This isn’t me going to extremes. Neither is it liberal propaganda. This is merely an observation of the undisputed facts surrounding Donald Trump’s life. Everyone with a brain (and that includes you) knows what kind of person he is. People who are paying attention recognize the embarrassing hypocrisy of Christians supporting Trump. It is not lost on people. They see it. I see it. As a leader in the church, you need to see it too. For your own sake and for the sake of the people who might otherwise look to you. It cannot be ignored. Pretending that you can support Trump because of his policies doesn’t cut it. Only Trumpy Christians think that’s a reasonable defense. Everybody else sees straight through it. Following Trump is not radical. It is fundamentally defaulting on Christ’s example that we rise above the corrupt ways of the world and that we live by a radically different orientation in life. Supporting Trump is the exact opposite, and that’s where you have put yourself. This is a mistake. You are better than this.
And this leads back to questions about your shifting towards the neo-Republican platform instead of Trump himself. You may think this helps your case, but it doesn’t. The two things you mentioned as a defense of your planned vote for Trump were black welfare recipients and the transgender community. I’ll approach each of these in kind, but I’d like to share an observation I think you should consider. I have long understood that Christian churches (and individuals) react so negatively towards homosexuality because it is the one sin that most Christians don’t struggle with. It’s an easy whipping post because it’s easy to feel self-righteous and indignation at the issue. Divorce? Porn? Greed? Idolatry? Jealousy? Grudges? Rage? Yeah, yeah, whatever, BUT (clutches pearls) THOSE HOMOS! And then comes my Christian pastor-friend, (MR. X), who singles out black welfare recipients and transgender people as targets to impose his judgments on. Seems pretty safe since these are two classes of people whose issues you have never struggled with and never will. Does that strike you a certain way? Because I feel like I’ve seen it all before. Pretty convenient to vilify people and issues you’ll never deal with personally. It’s a suspect move.
But let’s go deeper. Regarding the segment of the black community you have in mind there are so many other things wrong with your assessment that it’s difficult for me to know where to begin. I still cannot understand how you’ve decided that systemic racism isn’t a thing. If anything, I beg you to educate yourself on the issue because it clouds your perspective every time we talk about race. I honestly don’t know where you get your information, but the history and evidence is out there if you bother to look beyond the latest episode of whatever podcast is presently in your queue. Seriously, even if you’re unwilling to go to a public library, at a bare minimum you should go to Google and type in: “Is systemic racism a thing?” Or: “Is systemic racism real?” Or: “Does systemic racism exist?” It’s one thing to simply be ignorant, but it’s altogether different when one decides to be willfully ignorant. So you have a choice to make when it comes to your beliefs about systemic racism: You can follow the facts or you can persist in your ignorance. Please do better.
At any rate, you said that eliminating assistance programs for the black community aligns with your faith in God because it is, according to you, what’s best for them, and that similarly, if that community didn’t have particular carve-outs or welfare programs, they’d be doing so much better. This is your position as I understood it. You painted in pretty broad strokes though, so feel free to put a finer point on any of it for me.
But pending further clarification, The first thing to point out about government assistance programs (welfare writ large) is that it has 4 main components: nutritional supplements which can only be used for (non-prepared) food, direct, in-kind medical payments, tax credits (which only apply to those with earned income), and direct cash infusions. Critics always focus on the direct cash payments and cite outliers where these are misused. I imagine cash payments is where you’ve also been led because it makes zero sense to argue that taking away food assistance and medical payments “helps” anyone, especially in our current economic system and commercialization of healthcare. And again, I feel compelled to mention Jesus’ teachings about treating others the way you want to be treated: Would it be hard for you to pay the full cost of medical services without insurance? Does not having to worry about the full cost of every medical expense make you lazy or irresponsible? And tax credits? These are only available to people who earn income during the year. Since requiring everyone to work is a big thing for Republicans, I’m not sure how you could have a legitimate gripe about this one. It would be all the more hypocritical of you to oppose tax credits since you receive the equivalent of $500 per month in tax credits just for having three kids. Does that make you lazy? Would it be economically motivating for you to have a fourth kid, just so you could get an extra $167 per month? Does the math make sense, cost vs. benefit of having #4? If not, then do you apply the same sort of calculations to black welfare recipients? If not, why not? Surely, it’s not because you’ve uncritically accepted racist attitudes, right?
And why did you single out black recipients of welfare as opposed to their white counterparts or all recipients together? There is a higher percentage of the black community in the United States on welfare than whites, but in absolute numbers, they aren’t much different. Your focus on black people is especially interesting since racist conservatives consistently focus on the same demographic when discussing welfare. So are you against all welfare recipients, or just blacks? Because there are no specific, racially designated programs that I know of. A cut to “black” welfare is a cut to “white” welfare too. These are some things you should ask yourself, because surely It’s not because you’ve uncritically accepted racist attitudes, right?
But the bigger point I’d like you to consider is that correlation is not causation, meaning that welfare recipients’ being correlated with single-parent households and poverty doesn’t mean that welfare caused those things. No, these households were already struggling, which is why they qualified for assistance in the first place. The cause of poverty and broken families across a community is not others lending a hand, but rather the persistent, generational lack of education opportunities and lack of steady work opportunities, especially those with even a modicum of benefits. It’s a lack of fair loans and affordable housing, lack of healthcare, lack of investment in schools and neighborhoods. It is the absence of these things over multiple generations, and that is not even an exhaustive list. But instead of advocating for addressing the systemic features that underlie the problems that have manifested in these at-risk communities, you just want to end the meager financial, nutritional and medical assistance they receive and pretend like those things are the source of the problem? Hell, (MR. X), you won’t even allow yourself to admit that systemic racism exists.
This is a problem for someone who claims to follow Jesus. Cutting basic, minimal resources from impoverished and hollowed-out communities while simultaneously refusing to admit or address the larger structural issues that led to the situation in the first place is not something that Jesus would do. At all. Your position also fails to account for the various successes that welfare has had in many communities, including those of black Americans. If you have doubts, I would refer you to Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society programs of the 1960s. Under this collection of programs the median black family income rose more than 50% and their employment in professional roles went up 100%. Top educational levels for black people increased an average of 4 years, and those below the poverty line went from 55% in 1960 to 27% by 1968. Yet even under this program, white people were still the largest recipients of benefits. It did wonders for most impoverished Americans, not just Black communities.
So what happened? There was a massive white backlash. Racists learned in the 1960s that they had to adapt in the Civil Rights era and do their best to redefine “racists” as only those who wore white hoods and burned crosses. “Principled” economic arguments against a welfare state and “wanting what’s best” for particular demographics offered an air of plausibility for the new, more subtle form of racism, which largely flew under the radar of most white Americans. With George Wallace as poster boy of this new racist iteration in the 60s, it was clear that they didn’t want everyone to do better. They only wanted themselves to do better, and they saw black success as a threat in what they saw as a zero-sum game, meaning that any improvement in one demographic had to come at the expense of another. It was only after it became clear that government assistance programs could make a tremendous difference for people of color that receiving such help began to be stigmatized and cast as a handout to lazy types who didn’t want to work. But they wanted everyone to believe that taking away help wasn’t “racist,” it was merely pragmatic, even “good” for these underperforming communities. Sound familiar?
And the push was hugely successful in turning racist white Democrats into Republicans (the so-called Dixiecrats) based on their fear and hatred of black progress. Those states have remained Red ever since. This is known as the “Southern Strategy” (please Google that one too), and Ronald Reagan did a masterful job cementing the trope in the minds of white America with his made-up “Welfare Queen” speech in 1976. He had done his best to limit benefits and cut people off of welfare programs in California as its governor, and did the same once he became President. The trope of the lazy, fraudulent, black, single mother was cemented in Republican politics, and it has only gained momentum. Even Bill Clinton, after vetoing 2 Republican welfare “reform” bills finally signed a third that reduced assistance to families even more. The point is that welfare, when allowed to function freely and generously, absolutely can help families rise, but it has been repeatedly cut and stigmatized over the last 50+ years to the point where it is no longer adequate to fulfill its potential. But instead of making it more robust and addressing the systemic issues that created its need in the first place, people like you want to finish it off. Again, this is not what Jesus would do. Your claim that this sort of Republican policy approach is connected to your faith in Christ is literally unbelievable.
It is not welfare that is hurting black recipients, it is a system that has worked for centuries to stymie any progress that the black community might otherwise be making. If you sincerely want to “help” these recipients of welfare, taking away what meager assistance their most vulnerable people are still eligible for is ridiculous. Instead of being kicked off assistance roles and losing benefits as soon as they meet minimum “poverty” thresholds, they should continue to receive benefits until they meet a higher, more sustainable threshold. Yes, it is true that in some contexts, it presently makes economic sense for welfare recipients to not seek marginally better employment because doing so eliminates qualifying for much needed assistance. So is the best solution to further reduce or take away all assistance to “motivate” recipients? Or would it be more helpful to expand coverage until higher, more sustainable levels are met? It is this latter option that has historically led to greater, long-term results, and it is the former option that we currently face, which was mostly led by racist Conservatives over the last 50 years. This is like a group dedicated to the failure of the automobile, which mandates that sub-par automobiles be made and then citing those vehicles’ failure as a reason to cut off any support for the industry. Quite the shocker, eh?
Christians are called to be legitimate advocates FOR the marginalized and poor, not suckers who serve as support for those who would otherwise seek to limit peoples’ options. You should educate yourself on the true source of harm in impoverished black communities and vote for programs and people who want to address the generational deficits, expand opportunities for them, and hold those accountable who would otherwise manipulate and discriminate against them. Any guesses as to which political party typically incorporates such moves? I’ll give you a hint: It isn’t Republicans. The bottom line is that it’s hypocritical to try and justify a vote for Trump on the grounds of “helping” recipients of welfare by stripping them of any help.
– – – –
Transgender communities. This is also problematic for your support of Trump as allegedly connected to your faith. Do you remember what I asked you when you stated your opposition to transgender issues was grounded in your Christianity? “What is it in your Bible that led you to that conclusion?” You didn’t have an answer. As I recall, you tried to play it off, saying it was tied to many things as part of your entire Christian framework and that you believed you understood God’s perspective on the issue. This is a problem. If there is nothing in the Bible that reinforces your opinion, then appealing directly to God and claiming that you know his mind on the subject is… wow. Danger, Will Robinson. I mean how often has THAT kind of thinking gone horribly wrong? And would you find it persuasive if I tried the same move? Again, we both know the answer.
So there’s that. You only have your opinion. I’ve also heard you cite various instances where gender dysphoria and transition has led to unhealthy outcomes for certain individuals, especially when these life-altering decisions are made too young. I don’t disagree that there are instances of such mistakes and complicated problems with identity and mental health. But acknowledging this is a far cry from saying, across the board, that all such changes and medical interventions are equally problematic and unhelpful. There is much evidence indeed that for some individuals, transitioning can be life-giving and healthy. You don’t seem willing to acknowledge that, so again I think it’s important to ask why? We’ve already established that there is zero scriptural support for your feelings. You don’t get to claim special access to the mind of God either. What else have you got? If it’s just your feelings, then ok. But let’s call it what it is: feelings. I feel differently. So what?
Unfortunately, appealing to our differing opinions won’t solve anything. But there is something else that can guide us here. As I already pointed out, Jesus has some direction on how we are to treat others. If you don’t experience any gender identity dysphoria and don’t want to “transition,” then no one is going to force you. You are free to make your own decisions about your own body. It would absolutely be wrong for a third party to force you to acquiesce to their messed up beliefs about your identity and subject you to treatments to “cure” you. I hope you would agree as much as I hope you can see where I am going once again: If you wouldn’t want someone to do that to you, how can you possibly say that your willingness to do it to someone else is in accord with the life and teachings of Jesus? You may very sincerely, from the depths of your heart, believe that transgender identity issues are immoral and wrong. But your feelings are simply irrelevant when it comes to the free choices of others. Jesus made no exceptions or caveats for his command. You simply cannot force others to conform to your particular religiously held beliefs and honor Jesus at the same time. It is absolute fraud.
As I alluded to already, claiming that you “want what is healthy” for transgender individuals falls short. Sometimes the healthiest outcome is transitioning indeed. You are free to disagree, but at this point I have yet another question for you: If you really are so concerned about others’ health, and your objections are not grounded in mere political justifications but purely out of the concern for others, why have you chosen the relatively murky areas of transgender (or black welfare) issues to focus on? Black people make up about 14.5% of the entire US population, and a much smaller percentage of that number represents black households on welfare. The number of people experiencing gender dysphoria and transitioning issues is even a smaller microcosm of the US population. As of June this year, that number is estimated to be less than 1.2% of all Americans, or about 3 million people. Most of those are not children, and in both cases, the conclusions about what is “best” for them is anything but settled.
The case is much clearer for gun violence. Are you concerned that it is currently the number one cause of death among children 0-18? Which political party takes that issue seriously? The case is clear about climate change too. It will literally and negatively impact billions of people, their economies and living conditions. Which political party takes that issue seriously? Are you concerned about the insane cost of healthcare in our nation and how that negatively impacts children and their families? Which political party takes that issue seriously? Are you concerned about the death penalty and how that intersects with your faith? Which political party takes that issue seriously? Are you concerned for the plight of immigrants seeking asylum in our nation to escape poverty and violence? Which political party generally takes that issue more seriously? Do any or all of these issues have anything to do with Christian scripture and the teachings of Jesus? Are Christians not asked to serve “the least of these”? Yet on each and everyone of these issues, Republicans are opposed to enacting anything that might legitimately “help” the relevant people. How can you say that you’re going to vote for Trump (and Republicanism) as an extension of your faith when they have set themselves up in direct opposition to a wide variety of the things taught in Christian Scripture? To put it nicely: You cannot. Your support of Trump and the current bent of the Republican platform is a huge mistake. It is hypocritical and inconsistent with the person I previously believed you to be. I still believe you are better and smarter than to stay mired in your current political-religious perspectives. I believe you can do better. The question is: Will you?
- – – – – – – –
Post Script: God’s only action in the world as fas as I can tell is possible through his followers. And while there are certainly exceptions, when I look at white Christians in America, I don’t see them serving God. Rather than radically following Jesus, I see them serving themselves. I see Christians doing mental and linguistic acrobatics to justify their own desires, fears, hatreds and political candidates. They think they can wrangle God into supporting THEIR agenda instead of committing themselves to his. It seems that you have fallen into this same category. I know that you may take offense at this, and you should. It is offensive. But the sad fact is that people like me have come to expect such things from “Christians” like you. The only thing that can change our minds is Christians putting Christ first, setting aside their own agendas of power, wealth, prestige, and political dominion. Until that happens, I just don’t want anything to do with their religiosity or their spiritual “insights” or “witness.” They’re not smoking what they’re selling, but they want me to take a hit? Hard pass.
PPS: I hope you and your family are doing well. I was nice to see you this summer in (City), even if our time was too short. Hopefully it won’t be the last time.
Sincerely,
-Corbin






This Tweeter, Scott Jackson @sjbr549, provides a classic example of a straw-man fallacy, or the informal logic miscue that attempts to assign and rebut an argument that was never made by the opposition in the first place. Neither Governor Northam nor the Virginia state legislature has mandated that its citizens hand in all their guns. This meme is nothing more than an effort to change the subject and get the gunutters all riled up and laugh at the allegedly unstable government. Ha ha.




I wouldn’t exactly hold China or the former Soviet Union up as examples for us to emulate. Nevertheless, the United States and its application of capitalism deserves criticism too. Whether we are able to admit it or not, capitalism has major problems, especially if you aren’t in the top 10% of our nation’s wealthiest individuals, and all the more so if you aren’t in the top 1%. Be that as it may, it wouldn’t be fair to throw out the worst examples of socialism and then press a case against the worst examples of capitalism. The reality is that both capitalism and socialism have embarrassing and praiseworthy examples that ought to be avoided and embraced at different points. But as much fun as it would be to explore the details, nuances, and anecdotal virtues of each economic model, the purpose here is to advance socialism as the model which best reflects the biblical ethic of an entire community looking after a society’s most vulnerable people.






